Its Fair to say from looking at that list, it's been a poor decade for wingers. Not one of them would even get near a Wigan/saints reserve team
That's a bit harsh, 2 or 3 of them have been class, Carney always seemed to me to be carrying a little excess baggage and Broughton had everything just not the luck with (and he still doesn't) injuries.
Surprising how there isn't really any stand-outs in this category. I think if Carney had stayed he'd have been the winner by miles. He may still be.
I have, weirdly, gone for Johnson as my other. He's scored fifty tries, a strike rate of just under a try every other game, plus he scored the try that kept us in SL and ultimately gave us Hastings and a GF.
Jake Bibby is a Francis Meli type player never looked that quick but was always there to score the Tries. In a way a goal poacher in football do sod all during the match then get the winning goal and grab the 3 points, Unlike Anthony Marital at Man Utd Who does Sod all but rarely scores !!